I was supposed to check after each battle, not at the end of the adventure! Well too late now, I rolled for them and they were both fine.
Time to split the loot.
Warrior had 6 Bronze Coins from winning melees.
Thief had 1.
3 Bronze Coins had been found and was divided between the 3 characters.
Next I roll to see what the Magical items are.
1 Potion - Eagerness
1 Potion - Strength
1 Potion - Healing
1 Iron Cloak
1 Dancing Sword
1 Armor of Protection
The Treasure was divided as follows:
Warrior goes first and after that the NPCs choose in an order laid out in section 43.0 Afterwards.
Warrior - Sword, Healing Potion
Thief - Iron Cloak, Eagerness Potion
Soldier - Armor, Strength Potion
Only the Warrior had a successful adventure and rolling for Improving Rep, didn't happen.
Both the Thief and Soldier had to roll to Decrease Rep as they went Out of the Fight. Neither dropped.